Map Name: 1-DorD
Author: Audjo
Rating On Last OMC: <none>
Position On Last OMC: <none>
Players: 8


Ratings:

Map Layout: 15%/30%
Eye Candy: 11%/30%
Playability: = 14%/30%
Triggers: 0.5%/10%
------------------------------------- 
Overall Score: 40.5%



The DVD's Position: 8th - 45%
Dewman's Position: 9th - 28%
Froggy's Position: 7th - 48.5%
------------------------------- 
Final Position: 9th


Comments (Note: all maps were submitted to judges anonymously to avoid biased reviews, so the judges had no idea of who submitted the map):


-> TheDvD:

Map Layout: 7		This map is very big and has a rather complicated layout with MANY bridges. Player bases are on islands.

Eye-Candy: 3		Aside from heigtened/lowered terrain, tiberium, waterfalls and some rough ground, the map is flat and boring. There is no lighting or anything.

Playability: 5		This is very hard to rate for me. You know the argument that what matters is gameplay and not graphics? IMO, it's only partially true for TS. This is map is so unexciting to look at that the gameplay becomes boring. I guess i'll just give half the points here, as clearly this map is simply unfinished.. it would have been a great map had it been actually finished and crammed with details (and cities!)

Triggers: 0		No triggers (Well there's a reveal map trigger :P)

Overall: 45%




-> dEw_MaN:

Map Layout:	3/10	There are some bridges missing, which just look like the author didn't take the time to add them.  Two players start way at the bottom while the other 6 are cramed together at the top, many players have little or no space to build.
Eye-Candy:	4/10	The sights are pretty boring.  Pretty well all template terrian.  Some locations have NOTHING and may of made a better start location for some of the players.  Lighting was okay.
Playability:	2/10	The tunnels I DID try trapped my infantry with that terrible bug, this should have been fixed before submitting the map.  Like I already said, some players have very little space to build while others have more room than they need.
Triggers:	1/10	Only trigger I saw was a map reveal at the beginning of the skrimish with this map, nothing exciting.




-> Froggy:

Layout: 5
Eye Candy: 4
Playability: 7
Triggers: 0.5 {Avarage of DVD's and dEw_MaN's}
Overall: 5


- basic map, no impressive features
- working tunnels!
- no active AI
- strategic atks possible
- veinhole monsters display wrong
- conclusion: there are tunnels, but map needs much more detail 



Contestant Words When Submitting:


- heres my entry, i wont be going for 'eyecandy' or 'triggers' ill be in this for 'playability' and 'layout' :) ty have fun :)...i will be finishing it eventually..